Flatting in Auckland: flatmate agreements and who is on the tenancy
Four people share a Grey Lynn villa. Two signed the tenancy agreement, two did not. Months later one of the signers leaves without paying, and suddenly everyone wants to know who owes what. The answer turns on a distinction that many flatters never think about when they move in: whether you are a tenant, a flatmate or a subtenant.
The explanations below follow Tenancy Services' flatting and subletting guidance. Check the current pages before relying on them, because tenancy law has been amended several times recently.
Tenant, flatmate or subtenant
A tenant has signed the tenancy agreement with the landlord. The Residential Tenancies Act 1986 covers a tenant, and only the landlord can give a tenant notice.
A flatmate shares the home with a tenant but has not signed the landlord's agreement. The Act does not cover flatmates. Your rights depend on your arrangement with the tenant, and you owe your share of the rent to the tenant, not the landlord.
A subtenant is a different situation again. When a tenant sublets, they become a sub-landlord and sign a separate tenancy agreement with the subtenant. Tenancy Services makes the point that a flatmate who shares the home and its facilities with the tenant is not considered a subtenant.
The practical consequence: if you want the legal protections of a tenancy, such as the healthy homes standards and notice rules applying to you, your name needs to be on the agreement.
Joint liability
Where several people are named on one tenancy agreement, they are jointly responsible. Tenancy Services puts it plainly: tenants are jointly responsible for all the rent and any damage, not just their own share. If one tenant causes damage or falls behind on rent, a landlord can look to the others.
That is the main risk of being a named tenant in a shared flat. It does not mean being named is a bad idea; it is the only way to have direct rights against the landlord. It does mean you should choose co-tenants you trust, and keep an eye on rent being paid. Tenancy Services also recommends tenants hold personal liability insurance (see contents and liability insurance).
Adding or replacing someone
Flats change. People move out, partners move in, someone's cousin needs a room for three months. A few rules of thumb:
- Changing the names on the agreement needs the landlord's agreement and updated paperwork. Do not assume a verbal "that's fine" covers it.
- Taking on a flatmate (someone who is not named on the tenancy) is generally allowed in the sense that a flatmate is not subletting, but check your tenancy agreement for limits on the number of occupants.
- Subletting requires the landlord's written consent, even if the agreement does not mention subletting, and if the agreement forbids it, it is not allowed. The landlord cannot unreasonably refuse. Subletting without written consent is an unlawful act that can attract a penalty of up to $1,000, plus possible compensation to the landlord.
- Assignment, where a replacement tenant takes over the departing tenant's responsibilities, is an alternative to subletting.
What goes in a flatmate agreement
The Residential Tenancies Act does not cover the tenant-flatmate relationship, so a written agreement is how you set the terms. Tenancy Services provides a free flat/house sharing agreement template on its flatting page. It is not designed for boarding house tenancies. At a minimum, record:
- Who the tenants on the landlord's agreement are, and that the flatmate is not one of them.
- The rent share, the due date, and who it is paid to.
- How bills are split (power, internet, rubbish), and whose name the accounts are in.
- The bond: how much each person contributed and how it will be returned. The bond is lodged against the tenancy, so the tenant named on it receives any refund.
- Notice: how much warning a flatmate or the tenant must give before someone leaves.
- House rules on guests, noise, smoking, pets and shared food.
- What happens if someone leaves early before a replacement is found.
None of this needs legal language. Plain words, signed and dated by everyone, are better than a vague understanding.
When flatmates disagree
Tenancy Services says the Tenancy Tribunal hears only disputes between landlords and tenants. A dispute between tenants or between a tenant and a flatmate goes to the Disputes Tribunal instead, and Tenancy Services cannot advise on flatmate disputes. Community Law Centres and Citizens Advice Bureaux are the suggested places to ask for help. A written agreement gives the Disputes Tribunal something concrete to work with.
Ending a flatting arrangement
When the tenancy ends, a flatmate has no right to stay, because the flatmate's arrangement depends on the tenant's. Where a subletting arrangement exists with the landlord's consent, though, the landlord can give the subtenant notice at the same time as ending the main tenancy; if they do not, the sub-tenancy carries on and the landlord becomes the subtenant's landlord. Without consent, a sub-tenancy ends when the original tenancy does.
If you are leaving a shared tenancy, follow the normal notice rules in ending a tenancy, and sort out the bond split before the final inspection so the refund is not held up.
This is general information and not legal advice.