The Tenancy Tribunal: how a dispute works
Most tenancy problems end with an email, a repair or a bond refund. A few do not, and for those the Tenancy Tribunal is the place that decides. It is a specialist forum designed for tenants and landlords to use without lawyers, and it is a good deal less intimidating than its name suggests. This article explains how a dispute moves from a disagreement to a binding order, as the process stands in November 2026. Tenancy law and procedures change, including fees and forms, so check Tenancy Services before you apply.
What the Tribunal is for
Tenancy Services describes the Tribunal as the body that helps with tenancy issues landlords and tenants cannot resolve themselves. It hears both sides and can issue an order that is legally binding. Common disputes involve bond refunds, unpaid rent, damage, cleaning costs, repairs that have not been done and notices to end a tenancy.
The Tribunal can award compensation or order work up to a value of $100,000. Claims above that can be filed in the District Court.
Try to resolve it first
Tenancy Services notes that issues can sometimes be settled through good communication or through mediation, where both parties try to agree on a solution. Before you apply, it is worth doing the basics:
- State the problem and what you want in writing.
- Give the other side a reasonable time to respond.
- Where the law provides a formal step, use it. For repairs, that is the 14-day notice to remedy.
- Keep copies of everything.
A written record that you tried to sort it out is useful evidence if you do go on to a hearing.
Mediation
Disputes often go to mediation first. A mediator helps the two sides reach agreement, and if they do, the outcome can be recorded as a mediator's order. According to Tenancy Services' list of order types, a decision after mediation or a hearing can be a mediator's order, a sealed mediator's order or a Tenancy Tribunal order. If agreement is not reached, either side can ask for a hearing.
Applying
Tenancy Services processes the application and arranges the time and place. You can apply online, or with a paper form. There is a fee. Community Law's manual puts it at $20.44, though other guides quote different figures, so check the current amount with Tenancy Services before you apply.
When you apply, be specific about what you are asking for: an amount of money, a repair, a bond split, or the end of the tenancy. The Tribunal can only make orders about what has been put to it, and clear claims with supporting documents are easier to decide.
The hearing
Hearings may be held at a court, by phone or by online video. They are less formal than a normal court hearing, but rules and procedures still apply. A case conference, usually the first meeting between the adjudicator and the parties, may also take place.
According to Community Law's tenancy manual, parties usually represent themselves, though lawyers are allowed in limited cases such as disputes over $6,000. You can bring a support person. Bring your evidence, including two extra copies for the adjudicator and the other party. Hearings are usually public, and missing one can lead to your case being dismissed, so attend, or contact the Tribunal ahead of time if you cannot.
Useful evidence in tenancy disputes tends to be ordinary:
- the tenancy agreement and any property reports from the start and end of the tenancy,
- dated photographs,
- emails and messages,
- receipts, invoices and quotes,
- rent and bond records.
What the Tribunal can order
Tenancy Services lists the main types of orders:
- Orders to regain possession, for example where a tenant has abandoned the tenancy, is more than 21 days behind in rent, has substantially damaged the property, or has not fixed a breach within 14 days of a notice to remedy.
- Monetary orders, such as overdue rent, a refund of overpaid rent, or the costs of damage, cleaning or rubbish removal. Exemplary damages, a penalty, can be awarded for certain legal breaches such as not paying the bond to Tenancy Services.
- Work orders, requiring a landlord or tenant to carry out maintenance or repairs. Health and safety work, including smoke alarms and insulation, cannot be paid off instead of being done.
- Bond payment orders, which set how much of the bond each person receives.
- Debt recovery cost orders, available to a landlord only where the tenancy agreement permits it.
- Compensation orders, for loss caused by another person's act or omission, such as a landlord disposing of a tenant's goods without following the proper process.
Where a landlord misses a deadline for work ordered for a tenant, the tenant may be able to pay rent to MBIE until enough is held to do the work, or do the work and offset the cost against rent, but the party must request this and the order must include the options.
After the decision
Orders are legally binding. If the other party does not comply, Community Law says you can go to the District Court to enforce the order.
If you disagree with a decision, the options are narrow. A rehearing is available only where something went seriously wrong, such as not being told about the hearing, being unable to present your case, or new key evidence emerging, and disagreement alone is not enough. An appeal to the District Court is possible where the order was for money or work worth $1,000 or more, on the grounds that the Tribunal got the facts or the law wrong. Community Law says an appeal must be filed within 10 working days and the time limit has no exceptions.
Practical tips for both sides
Be calm, specific and brief. Explain what happened in order, point to documents, and say what outcome you want. Landlords should be ready to show that damage goes beyond fair wear and tear, and tenants should be ready to show that it was neither careless nor intentional. Neither side gains from exaggeration. An adjudicator reads many cases, and a modest, well-documented claim tends to be more persuasive than a large, vague one.
Think about whether a hearing is proportionate. A small bond dispute may be quicker to settle by agreement, but a real breach, an unfixed health and safety problem or a sizeable claim is exactly what the Tribunal exists for. If you are unsure, Community Law's tenancy manual is a good place to read further before you decide.
Sources
- Tenancy Services: Tenancy Tribunal
- Tenancy Services: types of Tenancy Tribunal orders
- Community Law: the Tenancy Tribunal